Gavin Stevens’s Painful Love for Eula Snopes

Spoilers: Major events and the endings of The Hamlet, The Town, and The Mansion are discussed below.
Gavin Stevens, a lawyer in Jefferson, has loved Eula Snopes for eighteen years when she calls him Gavin. He remembers having spoken with her only twice before. Those two conversations have furnished a life of expectation; the third brings the sound he has wanted to hear, attached to a request concerning another woman.
“Marry her, Gavin.”
Eula means her daughter, Linda. Faulkner places the long-awaited first name at the end of an imperative that sends Gavin’s devotion elsewhere. Its intimacy is genuine: she has come because she needs him. Yet the future she asks him to imagine contains her daughter in the place where he has imagined Eula. A few ordinary words accommodate recognition, disappointment, trust, and an obligation he cannot yet measure.
Faulkner gives Gavin years in which to think about Eula, very little time in which to speak with her, and an enormous amount to do after she is gone. The disproportion shapes the narration itself. We spend pages inside his attempts to understand a woman whose brief replies repeatedly outrun him.
Before Gavin: the woman everyone imagines
Gavin does not appear in The Hamlet. The first novel tells the history he will inherit: Eula’s life as Will Varner’s daughter, her pregnancy by Hoake McCarron, and her marriage to Flem Snopes. Her marriage helps join Flem’s advancement to the Varner family’s wealth and standing.
A reader arriving at Gavin’s romance through this history already knows that Eula’s beauty has material consequences for other people.
Faulkner also establishes a disturbing habit of perception. Eula’s introduction expands her into a figure of fertility through images of honey, grapes, and the crushed vine. The language is magnificent, but its magnificence makes her difficult to meet as an ordinary person. She becomes larger than the people around her before we have learned much about what she wants.
Labove, her schoolteacher, carries this imaginative appropriation into grotesque violence. During his assault he mixes fragments of Greek and Latin verse with obscenities. Eula repels him. We should preserve the moral distance between Labove and Gavin, yet the earlier episode prepares a question that will trouble the later love: what can an educated man’s eloquence conceal from the man himself?
The books connect through that recurring act of interpretation as well as through marriages and money. Eula enters Gavin’s life already surrounded by other men’s explanations. His tenderness will have to struggle with a habit the trilogy has taught us to hear: making her extraordinary can become a way of failing to listen to her.
The offer he cannot accept
In The Town, Gavin’s rivalry with Manfred de Spain, Eula’s lover, first exposes him to comedy. His indignation becomes jealousy, jealousy becomes a fight, and the would-be protector needs protecting from his own humiliation. Faulkner allows us to see how foolish love makes him before asking us to inhabit its suffering.
During the office visit in Chapter Five, Eula offers Gavin sexual intimacy. He refuses. The woman he desires comes within reach, and his imagined relation with her cannot accommodate what she offers.
“I thought that was what you wanted.”
Her sentence is almost painfully serviceable. Gavin has surrounded the encounter with questions of dignity, pity, desire, and what accepting her would mean. Eula brings him back to the purpose she understood him to have. To him, accepting her offer would mean accepting her pity, as though his longing were a nuisance she could easily relieve.
His refusal protects his pride and prolongs the deprivation under which he suffers.
The prose makes this conflict happen during the telling. Gavin turns the lights on to protect her reputation, then sees that the illumination may advertise her presence. He imagines the manner of her arrival, hears it, measures the sound against his expectation, and revises again. A practical decision cannot remain practical for long; each possible meaning produces another response before the encounter has moved very far.
The trilogy’s shifting narrators complicate the term “stream of consciousness.” Gavin tells the story afterward in the first person, yet the narration repeatedly returns to what he thought, expected, and reconsidered in the room. The recurrent tag “I said, cried” makes even Gavin’s account of his own speech unstable: the second verb exposes an intensity the first cannot contain. His sentences keep reopening decisions that Eula’s few words seem to close.
She is in the room; much of the encounter still takes place between Gavin and his expectations.
What Eula asks him to swear
Their last conversation returns us to the office. The setting brings the earlier refusal into the room without needing Gavin to explain it afresh. Eula again has something definite to ask; again, his response grows through qualifications.
Eula reports that de Spain has agreed to sell his bank stock to Flem and leave with her. Gavin immediately thinks of Linda: she must either leave with her mother or remain amid the scandal and discover that Flem is not her father. The transaction that would settle the rivalry over the bank threatens the girl’s sense of belonging. Eula’s love affair, Flem’s rise, and Gavin’s attachment now converge on the question of who will care for Linda. The Snopes trilogy character map helps keep those relations visible; the scene makes us feel why they cannot be untangled harmlessly.
Gavin’s first answer to the marriage request is conditional. He imagines a future in which Linda needs him, other remedies fail, and she freely chooses him. These reservations contain decency: he does not want to make her distress a means of obtaining her. They also give him time to think. Eula presses further: he must help Linda even if she will not marry him.
“Swear.”
At last he answers:
“At any time. Anywhere. No matter what happens.”
The change in syntax makes the commitment audible. Conditions fall away; the fragments extend its reach through time, place, and circumstance. His voice has spent so much of the novel elaborating possibilities that this surrender of qualification feels enormous. He has agreed to something whose consequences cannot be rehearsed.
Gavin does not know that Eula will die that night. His later telling does. As he remembers watching her disappear through her doorway, the narration begins correcting its own language of absence, trying to distinguish a person who has gone from one who never existed. Retrospection brings the knowledge of her death into a moment when he could not act on it. We undergo that divided time with him: the scene still contains a chance to speak, but the voice telling it knows that the chance has ended.
The face he keeps correcting
The Mansion returns to the aftermath through Ratliff. Gavin can tell us how much a sentence hurt him; Ratliff can show us what his friend does when he has exhausted the sentences available to him.
Gavin arranges the funeral and helps oversee Eula’s monument. He searches for photographs and repeatedly corrects the likeness being prepared in Italy. Ratliff finds the proposed face beautiful. Gavin finds an ear, a jawline, a mouth that is wrong.
Beauty in general is no longer sufficient. The man who has helped turn Eula into an ideal now insists upon the small features that make this face hers. He cannot draw well enough to correct the drafts cleanly, but he keeps trying. Faulkner entrusts the tenderness to an inadequate pencil: the task exceeds Gavin’s skill, and still he cannot leave it alone.
His labor also gives him somewhere to put the time. Ratliff’s narration insists, with increasing cruelty, that Gavin is contented now, relieved of his former anxieties. The assertion could almost be plausible: there will be no new rival to fear. But the details keep contradicting it. Ratliff brings Chick, Gavin’s nephew, to the unveiling because he suspects that one companion may not be enough.
On the return journey Gavin talks about absurd improvements to football. The talk continues into his office. He tries to light an empty pipe; Chick fills it for him; Gavin drops the filled pipe into the wastebasket and goes on talking.
Faulkner carries this succession through one long sentence. The football speculation and the small physical disasters share its forward movement, so Gavin’s conversation continues across the points at which we expect him to notice what he is doing.
Consciousness is now revealed from outside, through a failure to coordinate speech and action. He keeps inventing rules for a game while failing to complete the familiar sequence required to smoke.
Ratliff responds by getting him a drink. Because these men understand how a pipe is filled and what their friend ordinarily does with it, they can perceive a collapse that his eloquence has not confessed. When Gavin finally cries, the tears complete something we have already watched happening in his hands.
The promise continues in another life
Linda carries the obligation beyond mourning. Her marriage to Barton Kohl, the Spanish Civil War, her widowhood and deafness give her a history Gavin could never have planned for her. Faulkner’s widening network of stories makes fidelity a succession of encounters with the unforeseen. Eula’s request survives in a woman who develops purposes of her own.
Gavin’s attachment to Linda contains guardianship, desire, and his memory of her mother. His loyalty has to endure the fact that the person he promised to help can choose a life he neither commands nor fully understands.
Nor does endurance guarantee moral clarity. Gavin helps secure Mink Snopes’s release from prison; Mink kills Flem, and Gavin comes to suspect Linda’s foreknowledge of the killing. The promise that sounded boundless in the office has reached circumstances in which its breadth becomes dangerous. Faulkner lets devotion retain its emotional truth even as it compromises judgment.
Linda finally tells Gavin that his two devotions have brought him nothing. He writes his answer so that she can receive it:
“We have had everything.”
Linda says no; he writes yes, then makes the word larger when she contradicts him again. He erases it to warn her to take someone who can hear with her on the drive.
Even here, disagreement gives way to a practical concern for her safety. He has been ridiculous, jealous, frightened, useful, and inconsolable. Faulkner makes room for all of those conditions within his loyalty, then leaves him still answering the daughter of the woman he loved.

Sources and further reading
William Faulkner, The Hamlet, Chatto & Windus, 1940, Book Two, Chapters One–Two: Eula, Labove, McCarron, and the marriage to Flem. Digital text.
William Faulkner, The Town, Vintage, 1961, Chapters One, Three, Five, and Twenty: narrative framing, the dance, and Eula’s two visits to Gavin’s office. Quotations follow this edition. Digital text.
William Faulkner, The Mansion, Chatto & Windus, 1961, Chapters Six–Seven, Nine–Ten, and Eighteen: the monument, Gavin’s grief, Linda’s adult life, and the final exchange. Quotations follow this edition. Digital text.



Comments