Why John Williams’s Augustus Is So Beautiful

Part of: The Deep Reader
This essay discusses the novel in full, including its ending.
Hirtia is standing near the Temple of Julius Caesar when she sees a group of senators coming up the street. In their midst is a slight, stooped man in a broad-brimmed hat. Her eyes are too weak to make out his features. Her son takes her arm and they move closer. As the man passes, she whispers the name she called him when she used to wash and swaddle him. “Tavius.” The emperor stops. When he recognizes her, he says her name twice and touches her hand. [1]
I count Augustus among the most beautiful novels I’ve read. In the first book John Williams assembles the emperor’s rise to power out of letters, memoirs, and public documents. He opens the second with the testimony of a woman who cannot write. Hirtia dictates to her son Quintus so that his children and their children will know what place their family had in Rome. In her account of the emperor, the first thing that matters is that the country air was thought to be good for him as a baby.
Before he goes, he tells Quintus that he must have the Senate take away what he has loved most. We hear him correct himself from “counsel” to “order.” He is still standing with Hirtia and her son as he rehearses the authority he will have to exercise in the Senate. He has already told them that he had a daughter. He leaves her unnamed when he speaks of the order. [1]
What Julia writes for herself
The next voice is that daughter’s. Julia begins her journal on Pandateria with the pitted volcanic rock outside her window. She is allowed to walk alone a hundred yards from her hut in any direction, as far as the black sand on the side facing the water. Sometimes the weather clears and she thinks she can see the Italian mainland. Her opening paragraphs make us feel the confinement through the distance she can walk and the much greater distance she can look. Only after we have been inside those limits does she give her name and say who will read her journal. She intends to be its only reader. [1]
Her old tutor Athenodorus taught her how to build an argument. On the island, with only herself to persuade, she still finds herself considering the order of her evidence and the style best suited to it. She could start with her birth and the names of the consuls in office that year, and she does, after she has tried beginning with the rock, her mother’s shouting downstairs, and the news of her sons’ deaths. We read far enough past the circumstances of her writing to see what it will cost her to return to that practiced opening. She is trying to discover whether she can feel grief again. Her education has given her a method to try. [1]
Near the end of the journal she uses that Roman dating formula twice. She opens the first account by establishing who the consuls were and what charges were brought before the Senate. A sentence of five words follows. “My accuser was my father.” The list of dates, places, and lovers that comes next is largely accurate, she says. When she gives the date a second time, it introduces the account her father kept out of the Senate. Some of her lovers were implicated in a plot against her husband, Tiberius. Her father feared that a trial for treason would give Tiberius a pretext to return with an army and could cost Julia her life. A charge of adultery gave him a way to have her exiled first. [2]
Julia goes over the public charge in her own words, then takes us into her father’s study, where he asks, as he explains the exile, whether she recalls his old nickname for her, “my Little Rome.” It belonged to their affection. In the room where he uses it again, her safety and Rome’s have become reasons he is sending her away. Both the nickname and the accusation come from the man whose face she can still recognize, in the dimness of the study, as the one she knew in childhood. [2]
What Augustus tells his friend
In the third and final book, on a sea voyage toward Capri, Augustus writes to his old friend Nicolaus of Damascus. He has a copy of the account of his public acts in front of him. The bronze tablets intended for his mausoleum, he calculates, will take about eighteen thousand characters. He copies the opening into his letter, where he credits himself with putting an army in the field at his own cost and restoring the Republic’s liberty. In the surrounding pages the old man remembers reading the news of Julius Caesar’s murder. With a few lines of inscription inside a much longer letter, Williams can put a public account of the emperor’s intentions next to the elation he felt after walking away from his friends. [3]
Augustus comes back to the morning he met Hirtia. This time the emperor remembers looking at a woman who was ready to die among her children, in the place where her life had begun, and wanting to tell her what he was on his way to do. “I could not speak,” he tells Nicolaus. Hirtia’s statement lets us hear how much he did manage to say. Only now do we learn what stopped him from going further. He imagines that, if the choice had been hers, she would have let Rome fall and saved the child. She never makes that claim in her own account. It is what her life looks like to a man who has spent his own deciding how much one person can be made to bear for Rome. [3]
From the yacht he thinks he can see Pandateria through the haze. Years earlier, from the island, Julia had been looking the other way, trying to tell the mainland from a cloud. She could go as far as the black sand. Augustus is free to sail on. He gives the island its name on the page, then tells Nicolaus that he has gone more than fifteen years without saying his daughter’s name or seeing her. She has been allowed to live on the mainland, in Reggio, for ten of those years. [1, 3]
Julia remembers admitting that she might have spoken wishfully about Tiberius’s death to her lover, Julius Antonius. She denies knowing of a conspiracy. In his letter, her father is certain she took part, and hopes she’ll go on believing that love led her into disgrace. In her journal, when Julia revisits the days before he sent for her, she considers whether she refused to suspect anything. We have already watched her run into the question he hopes she will leave unanswered. [2, 3]
When Philippus reaches Naples
In the epilogue, the physician Philippus writes to Seneca about the emperor’s last days. Augustus entrusted the letter to him. In Naples he learned that Nicolaus had died two weeks earlier. He kept the news from his patient because the thought of his friend reading the letter seemed to make him happy. The man who had spared Hirtia what he thought would trouble the little time left to her is now in the care of someone making a similar decision for him. [4]
Augustus can arrange for the Senate to hear what he did for Rome and for passersby to see it engraved. What he has written at sea depends on a young doctor carrying a letter to a friend. Williams gives that letter an entire book, enough room for the old man to thank Nicolaus for a shipment of dates, imagine them disagreeing as they used to, and go back to what happened in the street with Hirtia. Before they part, he reminds her what she used to call him. She says it again. This time she knows he is listening.

Sources
[1] John Williams, Augustus (Vintage International ebook, introduction by John McGahern, eISBN 9780307513595). Book I and Book II, Chapter One, I and II. Originally published in 1972.
[2] Williams, Augustus, Book II, Chapter Six, V and VI.
[3] Williams, Augustus, Book III, Augustus’s letter to Nicolaus of Damascus, entries for August 9 and 10.
[4] Williams, Augustus, Epilogue, Philippus of Athens to Lucius Annaeus Seneca.



Comments