top of page

Porfiry’s Interrogations in Crime and Punishment

Writer: David Lapadat | Music PhD
David Lapadat | Music PhD
2 hours ago
6 min read

Spoiler note. This essay discusses the investigation and the ending of the novel.

Porfiry asks about the painters when Raskolnikov is already on his way out. On the way up to the pawnbroker’s apartment, there was a door standing open. Did he happen to notice the men working inside? Raskolnikov answers slowly, “as though ransacking his memory.” He has plenty to remember. The trouble is choosing the day he can afford to remember aloud. [1]


He came to see Porfiry Petrovich, the investigating magistrate, about a ring and his father’s watch. Both were in pawn with Alyona Ivanovna, the woman he has killed. It is quite reasonable to want a family watch back, and the paper in which the pawnbroker wrapped the two objects bears his name and the date. Porfiry has seen the paper. Raskolnikov listens for any sign that the investigator can put him there on a later date. Dostoevsky has already shown us the murder and the escape. What we have to discover, at much the same pace as Raskolnikov, is how much of that night somebody else can put into words. [1]



Which visit does Porfiry mean?


Before he asks about the painters, Porfiry takes an interest in an article Raskolnikov wrote. It deals with people who can give themselves permission to break the law, and at one point Porfiry asks whether the author might count himself among them. Raskolnikov can debate that question. He can refine the theory, dispute a description of it, or decline to give an example from his own life. The question about the stairs gives him much less to work with. Did he see two men, or even one? Porfiry sounds willing to be corrected on the numbers. [1]


He went up those stairs to pawn the watch, and he went up again on the night of the murders. When he was coming down that second time, he hid in the apartment the painters had been working in. If he admits he remembers them, he will have placed himself in the building on the wrong day. The narration keeps two speeds in one sentence. Porfiry can hear the slow answer while we follow the hurry of a man trying to work out what the question assumes. [1] [2]


He says he remembers porters carrying a sofa and squeezing him against the wall. That supplies the sort of incidental detail a man might recall when asked to picture a staircase. Then Razumikhin, the friend who brought him, says outright what Raskolnikov can hardly afford to say. The painters were there on the day of the murders. His friend had been there three days earlier. Porfiry slaps his forehead and says he has confused the dates. He can do that because Razumikhin has made sense of the question as a simple mistake. Raskolnikov gets to leave without finding out whether it was one. [1]



The other door


By the next morning Raskolnikov has been called a murderer in the street by a man he fails to recognize. He still goes to Porfiry’s office at eleven. The written declaration he has brought about the watch is quickly put aside. When he asks whether Porfiry had meant to question him formally, he begins with “I believe.” He asks himself why he said it, then why he is so worried that he said it. Dostoevsky gives us both thoughts in quick succession. Raskolnikov has barely spoken before he starts listening to himself for evidence of agitation. [3]


He gets a speech about why an investigator might leave a suspect at large until his fear drives him to furnish a “mathematical proof.” All the while Porfiry keeps moving around the room. Raskolnikov thinks he sees him stop twice by a door as if listening. Eventually Raskolnikov makes the charge explicit himself. If Porfiry has grounds to arrest him for the murder of both women, let him do it. [3]


Then Porfiry speaks of the empty apartment. He knows Raskolnikov went back there, rang the bell, and asked about the blood. He can tell that story as the conduct of a sick man revisiting a place that has got into his head. He can also voice the questions he would have put to a suspect about the visit. Raskolnikov hears both speeches from the same man in the space of a few minutes. When he makes for the exit, Porfiry points to a locked door and tells him his “little surprise” is sitting behind it. Raskolnikov thinks there might be people listening. Before he can find out, he hears a commotion at the other door. [3]


Nikolay, one of the painters, pushes past a warder, drops to his knees and says he killed the women. Porfiry, who has spent much of the interview telling Raskolnikov what a man might do under pressure, now has to ask Nikolay whom he killed, what he used, and whether he did it alone. He looks from one man to the other. Dostoevsky has given him, in front of witnesses, the very declaration he has been trying to elicit. It comes from a man the reader knows to be innocent of the murders. [4]


We find out who was behind the locked door only when the man from the street comes to Raskolnikov’s room and asks forgiveness. He was at the building during the later visit, heard Raskolnikov asking about the blood, and took that story to Porfiry. He was telling the truth about a visit that took place after the murders. His readiness to call Raskolnikov a murderer rested on what he made of it. Raskolnikov had expected the false confession to fall apart and bring the investigation back to him. Now that he knows what testimony the man can give, he thinks he can defend himself even then. [4]



A fact Porfiry keeps to himself


For their third encounter Porfiry comes to Raskolnikov’s room. At first he talks about cigarettes, and Raskolnikov thinks he is back to his old methods. But once Porfiry explains why he doubts Nikolay’s story, Raskolnikov can’t help asking who the murderer is. “Why, you, Rodion Romanovitch!” Porfiry says, almost in a whisper. He tells him again after Raskolnikov objects. For about ten minutes neither speaks. When they resume, Porfiry draws attention to the fact that they are alone. He can tell Raskolnikov exactly what he believes. Raskolnikov can hear him out without giving an answer anyone else can use. [5]


Deborah A. Martinsen singles out the bell as the detail that clinches Porfiry’s conviction. He remembers how he shivered when he heard about it. In telling that part of the story he recalls believing he had found his little fact. Later, when Raskolnikov asks whether he might still be wrong, Porfiry again says he has “a little fact.” This time he refuses to say what it is. We can follow his account of what convinced him almost to the point at which we could check his claim for ourselves. There the account stops. Raskolnikov is being asked to decide whether to confess while he still has to guess what case he would face if he kept quiet. [5] [6]


Porfiry offers him a day or two and says a voluntary surrender would help his sentence. Raskolnikov says he doesn’t care about that. On his way out, Porfiry asks for something more modest. Should Raskolnikov kill himself in the time he has been given, he should leave “only two lines, and mention the stone.” We know the stone. We watched Raskolnikov tip the stolen things into a hollow beneath it. He later described almost the same act to the police clerk Zametov as what he would do if he had committed the crime. Porfiry knows about that conversation. His request for a note gives that old hypothetical a new purpose. Two lines from the man who put the things there could tell the police where to look. [5] [7]


By then Raskolnikov has already told Sonya what he did. When he eventually goes to the police station, he nearly leaves without telling the officer why he came. He sees Sonya in the yard. She clasps her hands, and he goes back upstairs. Ilya Petrovich, the officer at the desk, calls for water. At the second interview Porfiry had offered him water. Raskolnikov had raised the glass to his lips and set it down without drinking. Now he waves the water away and says he killed the pawnbroker and her sister Lizaveta. People rush up on all sides. “Raskolnikov repeated his statement.” [3] [8]


Porfiry listens at a closed wooden door. Cover text reads Fyodor Dostoevsky, Porfiry’s Interrogations, and Crime and Punishment.


Sources and further reading


[1] Fyodor Dostoevsky, Crime and Punishment, translated by Constance Garnett, part III, chapter V. All English quotations are from the Garnett translation. Names in the essay follow common modern transliterations. Compare the Russian Virtual Library’s text of the chapter.


[2] Dostoevsky, part I, chapter VII. See the character and relationship map for the people and physical evidence around the investigation.



[4] Dostoevsky, part IV, chapter VI.


[5] Dostoevsky, part VI, chapter II.


[6] Deborah A. Martinsen, “Shame and Guilt in Dostoevsky’s ‘Crime and Punishment,’” Dostoevsky and World Culture, no. 4 (2018), pp. 40–64, especially pp. 54–56.



Comments


bottom of page