top of page

What Rudyard Kipling Trains Kim to See

Writer: David Lapadat | Music PhD
David Lapadat | Music PhD
3 hours ago
5 min read

A broken jar and a tray of jewels show how Kipling turns a boy’s way of seeing into a skill the British Empire is prepared to employ.


A full water jar appears at Kim’s elbow. Lurgan Sahib tells him to throw it back. The boy says it will break. It breaks. A moment later, with Lurgan’s hand on his neck and Lurgan’s voice telling him where to look, Kim sees the vessel beginning to put itself together. The water is still drying on the boards when he manages to stop seeing what the man tells him to see.


Rudyard Kipling places this episode in Chapter IX of Kim, in the part of the novel where adults are finding uses for a boy who has grown up speaking and listening on the streets of Lahore. The shopkeeper will train him for British intelligence work. Here he makes close attention dangerous. The broken curve suggests the whole jar, and the instructor’s voice turns that suggestion into an apparent restoration.


The Nobel Prize in Literature went to Kipling in 1907. The citation begins with his powers of observation. That praise has a peculiar fit with Kim. Observation can be trained, misled, and put to work for someone else. The shop lessons demonstrate all three possibilities through objects small enough to fit on a tray.



An arithmetic of broken things


Lurgan tells Kim where the next pieces will rejoin the jar, one on the right and one on the left. Kipling puts the instruction just ahead of the appearance that follows it. The jar begins to darken toward solidity in the boy’s sight. He can still see the porch through it. Kipling preserves the boards and spilled water inside the description of the illusion. We watch Kim’s perception change against objects that have stayed where they were. Lurgan’s voice predicts the restoration; the visible surroundings continue to testify to the break.


Kim has been thinking in Hindi. He resists by repeating the multiplication table in English, clinging also to the English word smashed. The sums interrupt Lurgan’s predictions with a sequence the boy can continue for himself. As that sequence holds, the shards, spill, and boards become visible again. Kipling interleaves calculation and perception so that the recovery happens in the prose: each return to a solid object weakens the suggested jar.


English schooling has armed Kim against a man preparing him for British service. Then Kim turns Lurgan’s command back on him, adding dekho, look, in Hindi. The sequence resists a simple division in which English means reason and Hindi means credulity. The boy uses both languages to recover control, first by changing his inward recitation and then by directing the teacher’s eyes toward the broken object.



What fits under the newspaper


Kim’s second instructor in this chapter is a child who can glance at a tray of stones and record more about them than Kim can recall after handling them. Kipling gives both inventories. Kim has counted fifteen and can begin collecting them in his head by color. The other boy identifies chipped or flawed stones, estimates their weights, and remembers one inscription clearly enough to say where a crack made another unreadable. He can identify the ivory figurine as a rat sucking an egg.


The two lists make expertise measurable. Kim groups by color and size, hesitates, and loses objects from memory. The other child can connect material, damage, origin, and use: a cracked turquoise has come from an old ring, and an apparently miscellaneous scrap is pipe amber. Such names organize what the eye records. Kim protests that the boy knew the stones already and demands common objects. The boy wins with those too, even blindfolded. Vocabulary helped, but repeated trials defeat Kim’s attempt to explain his loss through vocabulary alone.


The lessons soon reach the limit of what a good inventory can teach. After dinner Lurgan brings out clothes and paints the boys’ faces. He explains how people of different castes speak, walk, cough, and sneeze, including the reasons for their behavior. The child who defeated Kim at every tray grows clumsy in these performances. Kim changes his speech and gestures with his dress and delights in the transformation. Kipling reverses their positions without withdrawing the earlier victory. Remembering the marks that distinguish one object from another has not given the jewel expert Kim’s ease in imagining himself as someone else.


Kim volunteers to imitate religious beggars he knew in Lahore, varying his appeal according to whether he addresses an Englishman, a Punjabi farmer, or a woman without a veil. Lurgan asks him to remain in costume, sitting motionless, until a visitor arrives. The newcomer is Hurree Babu, another intelligence agent, and Kim greets him with roadside banter. To the boy’s annoyance, Lurgan watches the visitor instead of watching him. That change of attention gives the scene two different audiences. Kim wants appreciation for a performance; Lurgan studies a recruiter’s response.


Hurree asks how soon the boy can work as a surveyor’s assistant and announces that he will request him. Lurgan answers with the training Kim still needs at school. The adults discuss his next use in a few lines of conversation. Questioned afterward, Kim guesses that the visitor will want him when he leaves school, though he cannot yet imagine this unpromising figure mastering many disguises and languages. Kim is himself judging a stranger by his appearance at the moment his own performance has persuaded that stranger. The lesson opens a gap between his ability to deceive and his ability to recognize somebody else’s skill.


Lurgan’s authority extends through both kinds of lesson. Kim’s curiosity, already exercised across the streets of Lahore, becomes a disciplined capacity to retain, report, and impersonate. The reader shares the pleasure of his improvement; the British intelligence network will profit from it. These lessons leave the choice of what deserves attention with the instructor. Accurate observation can serve a purpose the observer has never been invited to choose.



The name with nobody to check it


At the railway station later in the book Kim sits repeating his own name. He has news worth carrying and can imagine dying before he delivers it. He asks who Kim is and seems for a moment to be getting near an answer. Nothing in the scene can play the part of the multiplication table. A passing Hindu holy man identifies the experience from his own pursuit of enlightenment. His recognition relieves Kim’s loneliness without solving the question. The training scenes ended with tests, results, and a teacher’s judgment. This encounter ends with companionship on a search whose answer neither man possesses.


Kipling puts a racial generalization about the habit of repeating one’s name just before the question. The description limits the novel in a way worth seeing beside its gifts. Kipling attributes the capacity for this self-induced bewilderment to many Asians and very few white people. The generalization precedes the individual experience as settled knowledge. The exact observation praised by the Nobel citation here coexists with a racial classification that the scene cannot substantiate. Kipling is more convincing when he makes a boy’s claim answer to a tray of objects than when the narrator exempts his own claim from such a test.


Start with the first Lahore chapter and the training in Chapter IX. The Project Gutenberg edition gives both. The book announces Kim’s descent from an Irish soldier and sets him among people to whom he can speak without the knowledge that English schooling will later give him. Then compare the two inventories under Lurgan’s newspaper. Kipling makes us read Kim’s omissions before the other boy names what he missed. We experience the distance between looking and knowing in the order of the lists, sharing the pupil’s defeat before we can admire his eventual skill.



A broken earthenware jar and a tray of jewels beside the title Kim.


Sources and further reading


Rudyard Kipling, Kim, Chapters I and IX and the railway waiting-room scene. The Project Gutenberg text preserves Kipling’s shifts of register and language.

Comments


bottom of page